Wed Nov 18, 2026 · rubric v1.0, pre-calibration

Last night's homepages, scored

Pages scored
23
Average
32.1/40
Hard fails
0
Not captured
5

Best homepage last night

HelloFresh

40out of 40, Strong

Food & meal kits · Product-led

Headline 5/5: Both checks pass. Product category in view: Meal photos (tacos, rice dish, salad) and text "Cook up 100+ mouthwatering meals in 30 minutes or less" show meals…

Lowest score last night

QVC

22out of 40, Weak

Department & mass · Storefront

Headline 1/5: 0 of 2 checks pass. Product category in view: A full-screen signup modal covers the whole viewport; only faces of hosts are shown, no product or category word… Hero offer: Primary text is "Sign up for sale notifications and get 15% off* today!" inside a blocking email-signup modal, not hero campaign copy.

Every homepage, ranked

  1. 1HelloFreshFood & meal kits40/40Strong
  2. 2Bed Bath & BeyondHome & furnishings39/40Strong
  3. 3Royal CaribbeanOther39/40Strong
  4. 4Rare BeautyBeauty & personal care36/40Strong
  5. 5SaatvaHome & furnishings35/40Strong
  6. 6Williams SonomaHome & furnishings35/40Strong
  7. 7Blue NileJewelry34/40Strong
  8. 8e.l.f. CosmeticsBeauty & personal care34/40Strong
  9. 9ParachuteHome & furnishings34/40Strong
  10. 10CotopaxiOutdoor & sporting goods33/40Strong
  11. 11J.CrewApparel & footwear33/40Strong
  12. 12PurpleHome & furnishings33/40Strong
  13. 13ArticleHome & furnishings31/40Solid
  14. 14Rothy'sApparel & footwear31/40Solid
  15. 15RuggableHome & furnishings31/40Solid
  16. 16AthletaApparel & footwear30/40Solid
  17. 17Old NavyApparel & footwear30/40Solid
  18. 18Banana RepublicApparel & footwear29/40Solid
  19. 19WayfairHome & furnishings29/40Solid
  20. 20EverlaneApparel & footwear28/40Solid
  21. 21GapApparel & footwear27/40Solid
  22. 22BrooklinenHome & furnishings25/40Solid
  23. 23QVCDepartment & mass22/40Weak
  • 33 to 40
  • 24 to 32
  • under 24
  • a 1 on Trust or Technical hygiene

Not captured

  • DICK'S Sporting GoodsOutdoor & sporting goodsThe site showed an error page instead of the homepage.
  • JARED JewelersJewelryThe site blocked our capture browser.
  • KAYJewelryThe page loaded without readable content.
  • Kohl’sDepartment & massThe site blocked our capture browser.
  • ZALESJewelryThe page loaded without readable content.

Sister sites: Inbox Teardown scores retail marketing email, and Social Teardown scores retail social posts.